Go to content

Recruiting staff: Shortlisting, interviewing and selection

This advice describes best practice in interviewing and selecting new staff members.

Overview

Once applications have been received, a fair and consistent process helps identify the most suitable candidates for the position. When shortlisting and interviewing dental staff, a well-managed process can improve how your practice is perceived by candidates, and show that you take your professional and legal responsibilities seriously.

You will need to be aware of wider principles around fairness and equal treatment throughout the process. The way you review information, compare candidates and reach conclusions should be rooted in the needs of the role rather than personal impressions. Taking a structured approach can help you navigate these considerations with confidence and consistency.

You will also need to determine how applications are sifted and progressed. Moving from a broad field of applicants to a manageable number requires a method that supports objective comparison. Making fair choices when shortlisting and interviewing dental staff improves the quality of candidates who reach later stages, and reduces the risk of legal challenges.

Engaging directly with candidates introduces another layer of judgement. How you plan and conduct this part of the process, and how you record what you learn, will affect your ability to assess suitability in a balanced way. Treating candidates consistently is particularly important.

Reaching a final decision often involves weighing up different forms of evidence and perspectives. You may need to reflect on how decisions are justified, and how you can demonstrate that outcomes are based on role-related criteria. A transparent approach helps reinforce confidence in your choices.

The final stages of recruitment focus on how outcomes are communicated and confirmed. How you frame next steps, set expectations and close the process with unsuccessful candidates are important for the professional image of the practice, and to protect against any claims of discrimination. Handling this well helps protect your reputation as an employer and supports positive engagement with your wider dental team.

Overall, shortlisting and interviewing dental staff is about applying structure, fairness and professionalism, ensuring that each step supports sound decision-making while reflecting the standards you expect within your practice.